It’s your adult child’s birthday. You open a text and type, “Happy birthday. I love you.” Then you remember what they asked you the last time you talked. Please don’t contact me.
You might sit there wondering how something so ordinary could feel so complicated. You want them to know you remembered. You also know they asked for space. Both things can be true, and you can decide what to do with that text without having to resolve everything you feel.
Estrangement can be a real loss
You might miss hearing about their day or sending them a picture of something that would make them laugh. You might miss the role you had in their life or the future you pictured together. And when someone asks how they’re doing, you may have to decide, right there in the middle of a conversation, how much you want to explain.
A review of research on estrangement between parents and adult children identified feelings of loss, stigma, and reduced psychological well-being among the experiences reported by people who were estranged (Blake, 2017). It can be hard to talk about a loss that people around you don’t know how to ask about. You can say, “I miss my child, and today is hard,” without sharing the whole history.
What does respecting their boundary look like?
Start with what they actually asked for. If they asked for no contact, that includes the birthday text, the gift in the mail, and the message you ask their sibling to pass along. If they asked to communicate only by email, stick to email and honor any limits they set on what they’re willing to discuss.
It can help to make a plan before a birthday or holiday. Write the message in a notebook. Ask a friend if you can call them that evening. Make plans for the part of the day you usually spent together. The goal is to give yourself somewhere to take the feeling when it shows up.
Make room for what they told you
In a study comparing accounts from estranged parents and adult children, the two groups tended to give different reasons for the estrangement (Carr et al., 2015). The researchers spoke with parents and adult children from different families, so the study can’t tell us what happened between any particular parent and child. It does raise a question worth sitting with. What did my child say about their experience that I had a hard time hearing?
Maybe they said they stopped telling you things because the conversation kept turning into a debate. You might remember those conversations as attempts to explain yourself. It can help to get specific about what they were asking you to understand. What happened when they told you something had hurt them? What did you do next? What would you do differently now?
If you’re working on an apology, you can write it privately. Try naming what you did, what they told you about how it affected them, and what you want to change. If they’ve asked for no contact, keep the apology with you. You can put what you learn into practice in the relationships you’re part of today.
You can get support while giving them space
Sometimes the hardest part is living with the uncertainty. You may still hope they’ll reach out. In the meantime, there’s a birthday to get through, a family gathering to decide about, or an ordinary afternoon when you really want to hear their voice.
At Small Works Counseling, I work with parents navigating estrangement from an adult child. We can talk about what you miss, what your child has asked for, and what you want to take responsibility for. You can start with whatever is hardest this week.
References
Blake, L. (2017). Parents and children who are estranged in adulthood: A review and discussion of the literature. Journal of Family Theory & Review, 9(4), 521–536. https://doi.org/10.1111/jftr.12216
Carr, K., Holman, A., Abetz, J., Kellas, J. K., & Vagnoni, E. (2015). Giving voice to the silence of family estrangement: Comparing reasons of estranged parents and adult children in a nonmatched sample. Journal of Family Communication, 15(2), 130–140. https://doi.org/10.1080/15267431.2015.1013106